Let’s face it – in today’s NFL, no quarterback is completely safe. Injuries, shaky performance, or just plain bad luck seem to hit every team’s QB room at some point. And when that happens, you better have a backup who can handle the heat.
In fact, we’re seeing around 60 quarterbacks hit the field every season thanks to mid-game swaps or temporary fixes. Last weekend, fans got a full display of this revolving door, with teams like the Browns, Colts, Commanders, and Raiders all turning to their backup plans. Some teams are ready to roll with a seasoned vet or promising young backup, while others… well, not so much.
Let’s break down which teams have the best depth at quarterback – and who’s most prepared for the next shake-up. Here’s a look at the teams that can survive a QB switch and keep their season on track.
5. Cincinnati Bengals
The Bengals discovered a gem in Jake Browning, who went 4-3 as a starter last season after Joe Burrow’s season-ending injury. Browning led the NFL in completion percentage (70.4%) in 2023, an impressive stat that demonstrates his accuracy and effectiveness in clutch situations. Projected over a full season, he was on pace to throw for nearly 4,400 yards and 30 touchdowns, making him one of the league’s most efficient backups.
With Logan Woodside in reserve, the Bengals have a dependable depth chart. Browning’s performance proved that he can step in and deliver, making Cincinnati one of the few teams with a reliable backup who can shoulder a season’s workload if needed.
4. New York Jets
The New York Jets brought in Tyrod Taylor to back up Aaron Rodgers, offering a veteran presence with ample experience. Taylor’s skill set—reliable passing, mobility, and a strong football IQ—helps him seamlessly fit into the Jets’ offense. Though the team is currently struggling at 2-5, Taylor provides stability behind Rodgers. Taylor’s 58 career starts and an 88.5 passer rating reflect his ability to make safe, smart decisions with the football.
Adrian Martinez, a UFL MVP, adds an intriguing layer to the Jets’ QB room. Rookie Jordan Travis, although injured, could develop into a promising asset. The Jets have thoughtfully cultivated a quarterback room that can pivot when necessary without a major drop in quality.
3. Kansas City Chiefs
Head Coach Andy Reid has a way of getting the best from his players, so don’t be surprised if Wentz looks rejuvenated when his number is called. Chris Oladokun on the practice squad gives the Chiefs a developmental option, creating depth that could become valuable down the road.
2. Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis struck backup gold with 39-year-old Joe Flacco. The former Super Bowl MVP has been crucial in filling in for rookie Anthony Richardson. In 2023, Flacco’s unexpected comeback led the Cleveland Browns into the playoffs, and he’s displayed a similar level of consistency with the Colts. Flacco’s stats this season—102.2 passer rating, 65.7% completion rate—showcase his ability to simplify the game with experience. His outings have produced impressive results, and his rocket arm has kept defenses guessing.
With Sam Ehlinger waiting in the wings, the Colts have the flexibility to maintain steady offensive output. Although Richardson is the future, Flacco’s presence offers Indianapolis invaluable experience and an immediate impact under center.
1. Pittsburgh Steelers
The Steelers boast a unique quarterback room. While Russell Wilson led them to a 4-2 start in his debut season in Pittsburgh, they also have Justin Fields—a capable, mobile quarterback who provides a solid alternative under center. Fields and Wilson are both scheduled to hit free agency after this season, which means Pittsburgh could have a difficult decision to make. Head Coach Mike Tomlin appears thrilled with both options, and it’s rare for a team to have two proven QBs who can contribute right away. Fields’ running ability and Wilson’s veteran acumen provide Pittsburgh with a dynamic and reliable QB depth.
Backup Kyle Allen, who has started 19 games, rounds out the depth chart as QB3, ensuring that Pittsburgh has multiple ways to sustain an effective offense if injuries or other issues arise.
